For years, the Pittsburgh Steelers have been synonymous with stout defense, with players like Jack Lambert, Mean Joe Greene, Troy Polamalu, and James Harrison solidifying the franchise’s defensive reputation. In recent seasons, one player has emerged as the modern face of the Steelers’ defense: T.J. Watt. The dynamic outside linebacker has become a fixture in the NFL, consistently wreaking havoc on opposing offenses with his relentless pursuit of quarterbacks and ability to make game-changing plays.
In 2023, Watt once again showcased his immense talent and leadership, putting up stellar numbers that seemed to place him at the top of the defensive player conversation. His performance throughout the season had fans, analysts, and experts convinced that Watt was a shoo-in for the prestigious NFL Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) award. Unfortunately for Watt, the award went to another player, sparking debate, disappointment, and a sense of injustice among many Steelers fans and supporters.
### The Case for T.J. Watt
T.J. Watt entered the 2023 NFL season with something to prove. Having been named the NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 2021 after a historic season in which he tied the single-season sack record with 22.5 sacks, Watt had already cemented his status as one of the best pass rushers in the game. However, despite his exceptional performance in 2021, Watt had yet to win a second DPOY, and there were whispers that he might be overlooked again in favor of other standout defensive players.
But Watt did not let that deter him. In 2023, he brought his A-game, putting together a season that was not just statistically impressive but also characterized by his sheer impact on every game. Watt’s 2023 campaign was filled with highlight-reel plays, clutch sacks, and relentless pressure on quarterbacks. By the end of the regular season, he had tallied 16 sacks, 36 quarterback hits, and several forced fumbles. These numbers alone were enough to put him in the conversation for DPOY, but his value went beyond the statistics.
Watt’s ability to change the course of games was a constant presence throughout the season. He single-handedly disrupted the rhythm of opposing offenses, forcing them to adjust to his relentless rush. Watt was also versatile, playing in a variety of defensive alignments and often drawing double teams due to his ability to wreck offensive game plans. Whether lining up as a stand-up linebacker or putting his hand in the dirt as a defensive end, Watt could do it all, and he made offenses pay for it. He had an uncanny knack for coming up with big plays in crucial moments—be it a game-winning sack, a forced fumble, or a key pass deflection.
Beyond his physical dominance, Watt’s leadership and tenacity were felt across the entire Steelers defense. As the team’s captain and emotional leader, he set the tone for the entire unit. Watt not only delivered on the field but also inspired those around him to elevate their performances. His ability to energize his teammates and change the momentum of a game made him an invaluable asset to the Steelers. In short, Watt’s 2023 season was one for the ages.
### The Contenders: Who Beat Watt to DPOY?
Despite Watt’s remarkable season, the 2023 NFL Defensive Player of the Year award was ultimately given to another player: San Francisco 49ers defensive end Nick Bosa. Bosa’s own case for DPOY was strong, and many fans and analysts understood the argument for his selection, but it didn’t come without controversy.
Bosa finished the season with 18.5 sacks, a career high, and tied Watt for the league lead in sacks. He also posted 51 total tackles and 19 tackles for loss. Much like Watt, Bosa had a season that left opposing quarterbacks scrambling to escape his grasp. However, the difference in perception came down to team success and overall impact. Bosa was on a 49ers team that finished with a top-tier defense, and much of the media attention centered on the collective dominance of San Francisco’s defensive unit.
Bosa’s ability to disrupt offenses, especially in key games, also played a role in his selection. But where Bosa may have had the edge over Watt in the minds of many voters was the consistency of his impact on a team that was widely considered one of the best defensive units in the NFL. The 49ers’ success overall, paired with Bosa’s individual performance, made him an easy choice for some voters, despite Watt’s equally impressive season.
Additionally, the timing of the vote and the narrative surrounding both players likely influenced the outcome. Bosa’s strong finish to the season, combined with the 49ers’ deep playoff run, generated a lot of momentum, especially as the race for DPOY came to a close. In contrast, Watt’s efforts were somewhat overshadowed by the Steelers’ mixed performance as a team and their failure to secure a playoff berth.
### Why the Loss Hurts: A Case for Watt
The sting of T.J. Watt losing out on Defensive Player of the Year is amplified when you consider a few key factors. First and foremost, Watt’s numbers were incredibly impressive and reflected his ability to change the course of games. While Bosa’s sack total was slightly higher, Watt’s overall impact on games—his ability to disrupt drives, force turnovers, and change the momentum—was felt more consistently. For example, Watt’s playmaking ability in critical moments of games is something that set him apart from other pass rushers. He proved time and again that he could make the difference between a win and a loss.
Secondly, Watt’s overall versatility as a player deserves recognition. Unlike many pass rushers who are only effective when rushing the passer from a specific alignment, Watt showcased his ability to excel in a variety of roles within the Steelers’ defensive scheme. Whether it was setting the edge in the run game or dropping into coverage, Watt demonstrated the skill set of an all-around defender, making him far more than just a one-dimensional pass rusher.
But perhaps most frustrating for Watt’s supporters is the fact that his individual performance was often undermined by the Steelers’ collective struggles. Pittsburgh’s offense was inconsistent throughout the season, and the team’s inability to make the playoffs surely impacted how voters viewed Watt’s DPOY candidacy. However, this should not diminish Watt’s contribution to his team. He played at a transcendent level despite the limitations around him, which only further proves his worth.
### The Bigger Picture: Watt’s Legacy
While Watt may have lost out on the DPOY award in 2023, it does not diminish his legacy as one of the best defenders of his generation. With multiple All-Pro selections and a rapidly growing list of accolades, Watt remains one of the most feared pass rushers in the league. His place among the NFL’s elite defensive players is secure, and his career is still in its prime.
The loss of DPOY will undoubtedly fuel Watt’s drive to continue proving himself. He has always been motivated by a desire to be the best, and this snub will only add more fire to his already intense competitive spirit. For Steelers fans, this moment may sting, but it also serves as a reminder of the greatness that T.J. Watt continues to bring to the field each week.
As the years go by, T.J. Watt will likely get another shot at the Defensive Player of the Year award. Whether he wins it or not, his career will be remembered for his unmatched passion, his ability to dominate on every snap, and his legacy as one of the league’s most impactful defensive players of his era.
Leave a Reply