From burn the ships to bend the knee: Florida State, Clemson stuck with ACC – like it or not…read more

 

In the ever-changing landscape of college athletics, conference realignment has become a staple of conversation, particularly with regard to college football’s top programs. Recently, the **Florida State Seminoles** and **Clemson Tigers**, two of the ACC’s most prominent and successful teams, have been the focal points of speculation regarding their futures within the Atlantic Coast Conference. For years, these schools have been seen as potential candidates for the SEC or Big Ten, conferences that seem to hold the keys to college football’s future. But in a stunning turn of events, Florida State and Clemson, like it or not, have found themselves **stuck** with the ACC for the foreseeable future.

Once seen as ambitious programs ready to strike out on their own, both Florida State and Clemson are now forced to reckon with their current conference affiliation. For the Seminoles, the situation is particularly complex. A once-bold rallying cry, **“Burn the Ships”**, which symbolized the team’s desire to leave the ACC for greener pastures, has now been replaced by the far less inspiring reality of **”Bend the Knee”** — a phrase that embodies their reluctant acceptance of the circumstances they find themselves in. So, what happened to Florida State and Clemson’s aspirations of independence, and how did they end up **stuck with the ACC**?

### The Rise of Florida State and Clemson in the ACC

Before we delve into why Florida State and Clemson are now tethered to the ACC, it’s important to recognize just how dominant these two programs have been within the conference over the past two decades.

**Florida State**, once the crown jewel of the ACC, was led by **Bobby Bowden** for over three decades. Under Bowden, Florida State became a college football powerhouse, capturing national championships in 1993 and 1999. The team has a long and storied history of success, including **multiple ACC titles** and a reputation for consistently competing at a high level on the national stage. Even in the years since Bowden’s departure, the Seminoles have remained a high-profile program, though they’ve struggled in recent seasons.

**Clemson**, meanwhile, has emerged as a modern-day dynasty under **Dabo Swinney**. Since 2011, the Tigers have been one of the top teams in college football, winning **two national championships** in 2016 and 2018. Clemson’s dominance within the ACC has been remarkable, as the Tigers have established themselves as the premier program in the conference. They have consistently recruited at an elite level, attracted top-tier talent, and proven themselves in the college football playoff era.

Despite their dominance within the ACC, both Florida State and Clemson have been targets of speculation regarding their potential move to other conferences, particularly the **SEC** and the **Big Ten**, which offer significantly more lucrative TV deals and stronger overall competition.

### The Desire for Change: Burn the Ships

For years, both Florida State and Clemson harbored aspirations of moving to conferences that could provide better financial opportunities, as well as increased exposure and prestige. The SEC, with its monster TV contracts and recruiting advantages, has long been seen as a tempting destination. The **Big Ten**, now expanding with the addition of schools like **USC** and **UCLA**, offers its own set of financial and competitive benefits. For these schools, staying in the ACC — which has historically been considered one of the weaker Power Five conferences — seemed less and less appealing.

In **2023**, Florida State, in particular, began to ramp up the rhetoric surrounding a potential exit from the ACC. **”Burn the Ships”** became a rallying cry for the Seminoles as they voiced their displeasure with the conference’s financial situation, its inability to compete with the SEC and Big Ten, and the general lack of competitive balance in the ACC. Florida State’s athletic director and administration, frustrated with the ACC’s **media rights deal**, which was signed through 2036, began exploring the possibility of leaving the conference to secure a more lucrative future elsewhere.

Clemson, too, found itself caught up in similar discussions. While Dabo Swinney has been a vocal supporter of the ACC in the past, there were increasing whispers that Clemson’s leadership was considering a move to a more competitive conference. With the **SEC** looking to expand and bolster its dominance, and the **Big Ten** growing in its own right, Clemson and Florida State were seen as key players who could elevate either conference to new heights.

For both programs, the prospect of leaving the ACC was driven by the changing financial dynamics in college sports. The power conferences, particularly the SEC and Big Ten, were reaping the benefits of major media deals, while the ACC’s deal was lagging behind, leaving Florida State and Clemson feeling somewhat isolated and underfunded.

### The Reality Check: Bend the Knee

Despite all the bold talk, the reality of conference realignment has proven to be far more complicated than simply deciding to leave a conference. While Florida State and Clemson’s desire to jump ship was rooted in legitimate concerns over financial disparity, the logistical hurdles to making such a move were enormous.

One of the biggest obstacles is the **ACC’s media rights agreement**. The ACC’s contract, signed in 2016 and running through 2036, locks its members into revenue-sharing agreements that are highly advantageous for the conference’s members — but not for those teams looking to leave. In fact, Florida State and Clemson (along with any other teams considering a move) would face massive financial penalties for trying to exit the conference before the agreement expires.

Both schools would also have to contend with the political realities of conference realignment. The **SEC** and **Big Ten** aren’t just looking for any team to add to their ranks; they want schools that not only bring value in terms of media exposure and fanbase but also fit within the broader strategic goals of the conference. Simply put, while Florida State and Clemson might seem like natural fits for either the SEC or Big Ten, neither conference is likely to be in a rush to make a move that would further destabilize the college football landscape.

In light of these challenges, **Florida State and Clemson** have had to come to terms with their current situation. The once-promising talk of **burning the ships** and sailing off to greener pastures has now morphed into a reluctant acceptance of their current reality. These programs are stuck with the ACC for the foreseeable future, and it’s become clear that, barring some unforeseen shift in the landscape, they will have to make the most of their situation in the conference — like it or not.

### What Does This Mean for Florida State and Clemson?

For Florida State and Clemson, this is a moment of reckoning. Both programs have spent years positioning themselves as contenders for the next big conference realignment wave, but that wave has yet to materialize in a way that benefits them.

Despite their frustration with the current situation, both teams are still well-positioned to compete in the ACC. **Clemson**, in particular, continues to dominate the conference, while **Florida State** has shown signs of improvement under head coach **Mike Norvell**. Both teams still have the ability to recruit elite talent and maintain a high level of performance within the ACC, but the reality is that they will be doing so in a conference that is increasingly viewed as less competitive than the SEC or Big Ten.

Ultimately, the decisions of Florida State and Clemson could serve as a bellwether for how the future of college football realignment will play out. If these two schools are unable to secure a move to a more lucrative conference, it will likely signal that the remaining conferences — the ACC, Big 12, and others — are more locked into their current configurations than many originally thought.

### Conclusion

The journey of Florida State and Clemson from **”Burn the Ships”** to **”Bend the Knee”** is a stark reminder of the complicated nature of college football realignment. While both schools once seemed destined to leave the ACC for more profitable pastures in the SEC or Big Ten, the reality of conference contracts, logistical hurdles, and institutional inertia has left them with few viable options. As they look to the future, Florida State and Clemson must focus on building strong teams and competing within the ACC while continuing to hope that a future opportunity might allow them to change conferences once again. Until then, both programs are stuck — but they’re not out of the game yet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *