theinfohub

The 2024-2025 NBA season has been a rollercoaster for the New York Knicks. They finished the regular season with a remarkable 41-41 record, clinching the No. 3 seed in the Eastern Conference. This is an impressive achievement for a team that had been on the fringe of postseason contention in recent years, and for many fans, it represents a new era of competitiveness. However, despite their strong regular season performance, the Knicks still face considerable skepticism regarding their ability to contend for an NBA Finals berth.

As the playoffs approach, the question remains: can the Knicks, with their balanced roster and hard-nosed style of play, make a legitimate push for the NBA Finals, or is their success more of a product of the parity and unpredictability of the Eastern Conference?

The Knicks’ Strong Regular Season Performance

The Knicks’ 41-41 record isn’t just an indication of mediocrity; it reflects a season of growth and development for a team that was once in the NBA’s basement. Over the past few seasons, the Knicks have slowly built a team that can compete with some of the NBA’s elite. The combination of high energy, strong defensive play, and solid offensive contributions has made them a tough opponent.

Under head coach Tom Thibodeau, known for his emphasis on defense and hard work, the Knicks have become one of the most disciplined teams in the league. The Knicks’ defensive rating ranks among the top in the NBA, which has kept them in games even when their offense isn’t firing on all cylinders. Julius Randle, the team’s star forward, has carried much of the offensive burden. His ability to create his own shot, rebound, and facilitate has been a major reason for the Knicks’ success this season.

Adding to Randle’s efforts has been the emergence of Jalen Brunson, the Knicks’ point guard and floor general. Brunson has proven to be a dynamic scorer and playmaker, often running the offense and creating open looks for his teammates. His consistency and ability to hit clutch shots have been crucial in many of the Knicks’ victories.

Despite the solid performances from their core players, the Knicks’ 41-41 record is still somewhat of a mixed bag. There have been impressive wins against top-tier teams, but also puzzling losses to lower-seeded opponents. This inconsistency has left many analysts and fans questioning whether the Knicks are truly ready to take the next step and contend for an NBA Finals appearance.

The Eastern Conference: A Minefield of Contenders

One of the main reasons for skepticism surrounding the Knicks’ title aspirations is the overwhelming competition they face in the Eastern Conference. The East has been home to some of the most dominant teams in the NBA, with powerhouse franchises such as the Milwaukee Bucks, Boston Celtics, and Philadelphia 76ers continuing to be the gold standard in the conference.

The Milwaukee Bucks, led by reigning NBA Finals MVP Giannis Antetokounmpo, have been the perennial favorites in the East. Their combination of size, skill, and championship pedigree makes them a formidable opponent. The Celtics, with their deep roster and dynamic duo of Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown, have consistently been one of the best teams in the NBA in recent seasons, and the 76ers, with MVP candidate Joel Embiid, cannot be overlooked.

In this context, the Knicks’ No. 3 seed may not carry as much weight. They are seen by many as an underdog team with a strong defense but without the same star power or depth as the top contenders in the East. While they have held their own against these elite teams during the regular season, there’s still a sense that the Knicks lack the firepower to go toe-to-toe with the likes of the Bucks or Celtics in a seven-game series.

The Knicks’ Offensive Limitations

Although the Knicks’ defense is their calling card, their offense has often been inconsistent and prone to cold streaks. Julius Randle, while an excellent scorer, can sometimes struggle with efficiency, and his tendency to settle for tough jump shots rather than attacking the basket can create scoring droughts. Randle’s occasional struggles with decision-making in crunch-time moments also raise questions about his ability to be the go-to guy when the stakes are highest.

Jalen Brunson’s addition has helped stabilize the offense, but he, too, faces his own set of limitations. While he’s proven to be an excellent floor general, he’s not necessarily the explosive scorer that many of the NBA’s elite point guards are. His size also presents challenges when facing off against taller, more physical guards in the postseason.

The Knicks’ supporting cast, including players like RJ Barrett, Mitchell Robinson, and Immanuel Quickley, has been solid, but none of them are viewed as genuine game-changers. While Barrett’s potential is high, and Quickley has developed into a promising bench player, it remains to be seen whether they can provide the consistency needed for a deep playoff run.

Ultimately, the Knicks’ offensive identity is centered on their defense-first mentality, and while that may win games in the regular season, the ability to score at will and hit clutch shots in high-pressure moments is what separates the contenders from the pretenders in the NBA playoffs.

The Playoff Experience Factor

Another significant factor working against the Knicks’ chances of making a deep playoff run is their lack of postseason experience. While veterans like Randle and Brunson have logged playoff minutes, they have not been able to get deep into the postseason with their respective teams in the past. The Knicks have only been to the playoffs once since the 2012-2013 season, which means their roster has limited experience playing in high-stakes games where every possession matters.

In contrast, the teams they will face in the playoffs are battle-tested. The Bucks and Celtics have multiple Finals appearances in recent years, and they have rosters brimming with championship-caliber players. For the Knicks, getting past teams like these will require not just talent, but the mental toughness and experience to handle the intensity of the postseason.

Conclusion: The Knicks’ Path to the Finals

The New York Knicks are a team on the rise, but their NBA Finals ambitions will likely hinge on several factors. They will need to overcome their offensive limitations and find a more consistent scoring rhythm in the playoffs. Additionally, they will need to rely on their defense and hope that players like Julius Randle and Jalen Brunson can elevate their games in the postseason.

However, as it stands, the Knicks are still viewed as outsiders when it comes to competing for an NBA championship. The skepticism surrounding their title chances is rooted in the tough competition in the Eastern Conference and their lack of offensive firepower compared to the conference’s elite teams.

If the Knicks can prove their doubters wrong and rise to the occasion in the playoffs, they may be able to make a deep run. But for now, the skepticism about their NBA Finals ambitions remains, and the team will need to continue building on their strengths while addressing their weaknesses if they are to be taken seriously as true title contenders.