Ohio State basketball has long been a pillar of success in the NCAA, with a rich history that includes multiple Final Four appearances and a proud tradition of competitive play. However, as the 2024 season draws to a close, it is increasingly likely that the Buckeyes will miss the NCAA Tournament for the third consecutive year. This marks a troubling trend for a program that has historically prided itself on its consistent tournament appearances and ability to compete at the highest level.
As fans of Ohio State and college basketball enthusiasts alike wrestle with this reality, several hard truths, biases, and a sense of apathy have come to the forefront. The Buckeyes’ current struggles are a symptom of broader issues that have plagued the program in recent years. While the reasons for their decline are complex, it is crucial to confront the hard truths about Ohio State basketball’s situation and the larger context in which these struggles are unfolding.
The Hard Truth: Decline Amidst High Expectations
For decades, Ohio State basketball has enjoyed a reputation as a powerhouse in the Big Ten Conference and in college basketball at large. Under legendary coaches like Fred Taylor, Jim O’Brien, and Thad Matta, the Buckeyes consistently found themselves in the NCAA Tournament, often advancing to the second weekend and even making a national championship game appearance in 2007. However, in the past few years, the program has experienced a steady decline.
The 2021 and 2022 seasons both saw Ohio State fail to reach the NCAA Tournament, with the 2022 team finishing with an underwhelming record of 12–8 in the Big Ten. Despite some flashes of promise, including a competitive non-conference schedule, the Buckeyes struggled to put together a complete season. In 2023, Ohio State’s tournament hopes were dashed with a loss in the Big Ten Tournament, leaving the team on the outside looking in for the second consecutive year.
Now, as the 2024 season comes to a close, Ohio State is likely staring at another year without March Madness. Despite the program’s storied past, this marks a disappointing and troubling trend. While some might point to injuries, youth, or individual player struggles, the deeper issue is the consistent inability of the Buckeyes to live up to expectations—both from within the program and from fans and analysts alike.
Bias in College Basketball: The Underrated Ohio State Program
Part of Ohio State’s failure to make the NCAA Tournament in recent years can be attributed to the program being somewhat underrated on the national stage. While Ohio State is a historic program with an impressive roster and coaching staff, it is often overlooked by a college basketball media landscape that tends to focus heavily on the traditional powerhouses like Duke, Kentucky, Kansas, and North Carolina. These schools, due to their blue-chip status and national name recognition, are typically given the benefit of the doubt in selection discussions, even when their performance doesn’t always justify it.
The Buckeyes, despite playing in one of the most competitive conferences in the nation, the Big Ten, have been subjected to a certain amount of bias in the eyes of many. In recent years, other programs from major conferences have been able to outperform Ohio State in both the regular season and tournament play, earning higher seeds or spots in the tournament even with questionable resumes.
Ohio State’s absence from the NCAA Tournament for the past two seasons, along with the likelihood that they’ll miss the tournament again in 2024, might be due to the perception that the program is no longer the dominant force it once was. In a sport that tends to lean heavily on reputation, Ohio State’s inability to consistently produce tournament-caliber teams has relegated them to the fringe of national discussion.
Bias also comes into play when considering the Big Ten as a whole. The conference has long been one of the most competitive in college basketball, but it has also suffered from a reputation of being a “tournament underachiever.” The perception that Big Ten teams, despite dominating the regular season, often fall short in the postseason can affect how Ohio State’s performance is viewed. The Buckeyes may be judged by a different standard than schools from other conferences, leading to their exclusion or lower seeding, even when their performance might otherwise warrant consideration.
Apathy: The Real Danger to Ohio State Hoops
While bias plays a role in Ohio State’s exclusion from the NCAA Tournament, apathy is a more insidious issue that has the potential to undermine the program’s long-term future. College basketball programs need passionate fan bases, administration support, and consistent recruiting to remain competitive. Ohio State has long had the fan base and the institutional backing to support a strong basketball program, but apathy from both the university and its supporters seems to be taking hold.
The fans who once filled the Schottenstein Center with raucous energy are becoming more disengaged, and the lack of a consistent, winning product on the floor is a big reason why. Apathy has seeped into the very culture of Ohio State basketball. Fans are less invested in the success of the program, and the broader Ohio State community seems to be more focused on the football program, which has been a perennial national contender. The imbalance between football and basketball in terms of attention and support is a well-known dynamic at many schools, but Ohio State’s apathy toward basketball has become increasingly noticeable.
At the administrative level, it has become clear that the expectations for basketball have diminished. While football remains a crown jewel for Ohio State, basketball has slipped under the radar. The program’s decline, including its likely failure to make the NCAA Tournament for a third straight year, suggests a lack of urgency in fixing what’s broken. Recruiting has faltered, coaching changes have had mixed results, and even player development has been inconsistent. Ohio State’s inability to keep up with the evolving landscape of college basketball only feeds into the cycle of underachievement.
The Future of Ohio State Basketball: A Wake-Up Call?
As Ohio State basketball faces yet another year without the NCAA Tournament, the program stands at a crossroads. Hard truths must be acknowledged in order for the Buckeyes to move forward and re-establish themselves as a force in college basketball.
First and foremost, the university must prioritize basketball and provide the necessary resources to ensure that the program remains competitive. The apathy that has crept into the program must be addressed, and both fans and administration need to make a collective commitment to the team’s success. This may involve more significant investment in recruiting, facilities, and coaching, as well as a renewed emphasis on building a culture that values basketball success just as much as football.
The team itself must also confront the reality of the situation. The players need to develop a sense of urgency and fight to perform at their highest level. Ohio State has talented players, but talent alone won’t carry a team to success; it takes a mentality of resilience, focus, and determination to overcome obstacles and make the tournament.
Finally, the coaching staff needs to acknowledge the challenges of the modern college basketball landscape and adjust accordingly. With the transfer portal and NIL opportunities reshaping the recruiting process, Ohio State must embrace these changes to stay competitive. Recruiting strategies need to evolve, and more attention must be paid to building cohesive, high-caliber teams that can contend for championships, not just for individual accolades.
Conclusion: Confronting the Truth for a Better Tomorrow
Ohio State basketball’s likely failure to make the NCAA Tournament for the third straight year is a bitter pill for fans to swallow. It highlights a series of uncomfortable truths about the program: the decline in competitiveness, the biases at play in national perception, and the apathy that has seeped into the program. However, these challenges also present an opportunity for reflection and growth. By addressing these issues head-on—acknowledging the decline, confronting the bias, and reviving the passion for the game—Ohio State basketball can begin the process of returning to the upper echelon of college hoops.
As the 2024 season winds down, the hard truths about Ohio State basketball must be accepted, but they must also serve as a catalyst for change. Only then can the program hope to rise again and recapture the greatness that once defined it.
Leave a Reply