The New York Knicks, a team once known for their dominance in the 1990s, have struggled to return to prominence in the NBA for much of the 21st century. Their recent resurgence, led by head coach Tom Thibodeau, has brought hope back to Madison Square Garden, with an emphasis on tough defense and grit. However, the Knicks’ path to true championship contention is clear: it lies in unlocking their offensive potential.
In today’s NBA, teams are more dependent than ever on scoring. The golden age of defense, where a team could thrive simply by stifling opponents, has passed. The 2024 NBA season is further proof of this, with most successful teams having prolific offensive units. For the Knicks to truly compete at the highest level, they will need to make significant strides in that area.
The Defense-First Approach
There’s no denying the Knicks’ defensive prowess under Thibodeau. New York has been one of the best defensive teams in the league, ranking in the top 10 for several seasons. This defense-first mentality is a trademark of Thibodeau’s coaching style, and while it has garnered success in the regular season, the playoffs require a different formula.
In the 2023 postseason, despite their solid defensive play, the Knicks were eliminated in the second round by the Miami Heat. The glaring issue was their inability to generate consistent offense, particularly in critical moments. While defense can keep a team in games, it is offense that ultimately wins championships.
The Knicks’ Offensive Struggles
The Knicks’ offensive struggles are not new, but they are more evident now than ever before. New York currently relies heavily on Julius Randle, a power forward who can score in spurts but is often inefficient and inconsistent. Jalen Brunson, acquired from Dallas, has been an excellent addition, providing leadership and scoring, but the Knicks are still a team built around defense and not free-flowing offensive creativity.
The primary issue lies in their half-court offense. The Knicks have struggled with ball movement and spacing. Their offensive sets often become stagnant, with too much isolation play and not enough off-ball movement. The spacing is inconsistent, particularly when Randle is on the court. With Randle, the Knicks lack the dynamic ball-handling playmaker that would allow them to consistently create open shots and get to the rim efficiently.
The Knicks’ three-point shooting, another critical component of today’s NBA offense, is also far from elite. While the team has shooters like RJ Barrett and Immanuel Quickley, they’re not consistent enough to scare opponents into altering their game plan. Without a reliable outside threat, the Knicks become too easy to defend, allowing teams to collapse the paint, crowd the lane, and neutralize their limited offensive weapons.
The Solution: Unlocking the Offense
The answer to the Knicks’ problems lies in their ability to evolve their offensive system. Here’s how they can unleash their offensive potential and make the leap from playoff contender to legitimate championship threat:
- Develop More Ball Movement
One of the most glaring weaknesses of the Knicks’ offense is their ball movement. Too often, their offense is reduced to isolation plays with limited player movement. To become a more dynamic offense, the Knicks need to develop a more fluid system that focuses on passing and cutting. Thibodeau needs to embrace a modern offensive scheme that prioritizes player movement, ball reversals, and finding the open man.
In particular, Jalen Brunson can serve as the catalyst for this change. His ability to run pick-and-rolls and facilitate offense will be crucial. But he needs to be surrounded by players who can move without the ball and space the floor effectively. If the Knicks can generate more open looks through quicker ball movement, they can stretch defenses and open up more driving lanes for Randle, Brunson, and others.
- Embrace Positionless Basketball
While the Knicks have excellent players in specific positions, such as Randle at power forward and Brunson at point guard, they need to embrace the positionless basketball trend that has been sweeping the NBA. This means getting creative with their lineups, encouraging players to take on multiple roles, and reducing the reliance on traditional positions.
RJ Barrett, for example, has the potential to be a primary ball handler in certain lineups, taking some of the playmaking pressure off of Brunson. Quickley is another player who can thrive with increased responsibilities, using his speed and shooting to create mismatches. The key to a successful offense in today’s NBA is adaptability and flexibility, and the Knicks must work toward this by experimenting with different lineups and playing a more fluid style of basketball.
- Invest in Three-Point Shooting
In the modern NBA, three-point shooting is a non-negotiable skill for teams hoping to contend. The Knicks have made strides in this area with players like Barrett and Quickley, but they still need more reliable shooters to truly space the floor and open up the paint.
The front office must prioritize acquiring sharpshooters to complement their core players. Whether through the draft, trades, or free agency, adding a wing player who can consistently knock down three-pointers would transform the Knicks’ offense. This player could stretch the defense, forcing teams to honor the perimeter, which in turn would open up driving lanes for Randle, Brunson, and Barrett.
- Utilize Julius Randle Effectively
Julius Randle is undeniably talented, but he remains a player with a limited offensive game. His ability to score in the post and hit the occasional three-pointer makes him a versatile weapon, but his ball-handling and shot selection can be problematic at times. Thibodeau needs to find ways to use Randle in a more effective manner.
Instead of relying on him to create offense in isolation, Thibodeau should design more plays that get Randle moving without the ball. Allowing Randle to use his physicality as an offensive weapon in pick-and-roll situations could open up more opportunities. Additionally, Randle needs to buy into the idea of being a complementary piece in a system rather than the focal point of the offense. If Randle can learn to play within a more structured, dynamic system, his talents could truly shine.
- Leverage the Youth
One of the Knicks’ biggest advantages is their young talent. Players like Barrett, Quickley, and Obi Toppin all have the potential to grow into key pieces for the Knicks moving forward. Thibodeau should continue to develop these players and encourage them to become more aggressive offensively.
For example, Barrett is a player with immense scoring potential, but he has been inconsistent throughout his career. Thibodeau should encourage him to be more aggressive and assertive in his offensive role. Similarly, Quickley has shown flashes of brilliance as a shooter, but he needs to continue to grow as a playmaker and decision-maker.
Conclusion: The Knicks Must Evolve
If the New York Knicks want to become true contenders in the NBA, they must evolve from a defense-first, grit-and-grind team into one that can outscore opponents in the modern NBA. This evolution starts with unleashing their offense, encouraging more ball movement, embracing positionless basketball, investing in shooting, and optimizing the talents of their core players.
Only by unlocking their offensive potential will the Knicks be able to compete with the best teams in the league. It’s a tall order, but with the right moves, they have the talent and the pieces in place to make this transformation. For Knicks fans, the hope for a championship may soon rest not just on tough defense, but on an offense capable of going toe-to-toe with the best.
Leave a Reply