Josh Heupel was hired as the head coach of the Tennessee Volunteers with great expectations. After a successful stint at UCF, where he led the Knights to an undefeated season in 2017, Heupel was seen as the savior who could bring Tennessee back to prominence after years of mediocrity and underachievement. However, as the 2024 season has unfolded, it’s becoming increasingly clear that Heupel is facing an impossible situation, and there doesn’t seem to be an obvious answer to resolve it.
The Tennessee Vols, one of the most storied programs in college football history, have found themselves in a place where the expectations are sky-high, but the on-field results have not matched the hype. Heupel, despite his offensive ingenuity and ability to produce high-scoring teams, is struggling to find the consistency and balance needed to make Tennessee a true contender in the SEC once again. And as the Vols’ struggles continue, it is becoming more evident that Heupel’s future at Tennessee—and the future of the program itself—are hanging in the balance.
The High Expectations and Initial Promise
When Josh Heupel took over at Tennessee in 2021, the program was in disarray. After years of coaching changes and underwhelming performances, Tennessee fans were hungry for a new era. Heupel’s offensive-minded approach seemed like the perfect fit for a team that had been stymied by outdated and conservative offensive schemes under previous regimes. His high-paced, pass-heavy offense was expected to bring a breath of fresh air to a program that hadn’t been able to find sustained success for over a decade.
In Heupel’s first season, he exceeded expectations by leading Tennessee to a 7-6 record, which included a thrilling bowl win over a strong opponent in the Music City Bowl. The offense showed signs of promise, and quarterback Hendon Hooker emerged as one of the SEC’s most dynamic playmakers. The Vols’ offense averaged 39.3 points per game in 2021, and while they were still far from championship contenders, the future seemed bright.
Heupel’s second season in 2022 brought even more optimism. Tennessee’s offense was explosive, and the team exceeded expectations by finishing with an 11-2 record. The Vols even knocked off Alabama in one of the most exciting games of the season, and Heupel’s offensive genius was widely praised. Hooker continued to develop into one of the top quarterbacks in the country, and Tennessee appeared to be on the cusp of returning to its rightful place among the SEC’s elite teams.
But now, in 2024, things have taken a turn for the worse. Tennessee’s offense has stagnated, and their defense, long an Achilles’ heel for the program, remains underperforming. Despite Heupel’s reputation as an offensive innovator, the Vols have struggled to maintain consistent offensive production, especially against the SEC’s elite teams. The same high-powered offense that brought so much promise in 2021 and 2022 now looks like a shell of its former self.
The Struggles of the 2024 Season
The 2024 season has been a microcosm of the challenges facing Josh Heupel and Tennessee. While there have been flashes of brilliance—especially from the offense—the inconsistency has been maddening. In a conference as unforgiving as the SEC, where top-tier teams like Georgia, Alabama, and LSU are at the top year after year, inconsistency is a killer.
Tennessee’s offense, despite having talented playmakers, has been inconsistent in execution. Quarterback Joe Milton, who was supposed to step into a leadership role following Hendon Hooker’s departure, has struggled to find his rhythm. While Milton has the arm strength to make impressive throws, his decision-making and accuracy have often been questionable. As a result, the Vols’ offense has sputtered at times, and the team has struggled to score points in critical moments.
The defense, which has been a longstanding issue for Tennessee, remains a glaring weakness. The Vols have not been able to stop high-powered offenses from exploiting their defensive line and secondary. While there have been some attempts to improve the defensive personnel through recruiting, Tennessee’s defense still lags far behind the elite teams in the SEC. In a conference where offenses are prolific and the competition is fierce, having a porous defense can be a death sentence.
Even worse, Tennessee’s recruiting, while solid, hasn’t been enough to close the gap between them and the top programs in the conference. They’ve had success in securing top-tier recruits, but the sheer level of competition in the SEC means that even their best players often struggle to make an immediate impact. The Vols’ ability to land elite recruits has improved under Heupel, but they are still not consistently in the same class as the perennial powerhouse programs.
The Impossible Situation
So, where does this leave Josh Heupel? The Tennessee fan base is growing impatient. After years of mediocrity, they have tasted success under Heupel, but they are also acutely aware that the program has failed to break into the upper echelon of college football. The Vols were hoping for sustained success, but as the 2024 season has demonstrated, they’re not there yet.
Heupel finds himself in an impossible situation for several reasons.
First, the expectations are sky-high. Tennessee fans want championships, not just bowl wins. They want to see their team competing with the likes of Georgia, Alabama, and LSU for SEC titles. Heupel, for all of his offensive innovation, has not been able to provide that level of sustained success. He’s not just expected to win, but to win big in one of the most competitive conferences in college football.
Second, Heupel’s offensive system, which seemed like a perfect fit when he was hired, has been stymied by the very SEC defenses that it was supposed to outpace. While Heupel’s up-tempo, pass-heavy attack was revolutionary at UCF, it has not been as effective in the SEC. Defenses in the SEC are more talented, more physical, and more sophisticated than those in Group of Five conferences. As a result, Tennessee’s offense has had difficulty sustaining drives and scoring against elite defenses, and this inconsistency has undermined their overall performance.
Third, the defense remains a major liability. Heupel, as an offensive-minded head coach, has not been able to transform Tennessee’s defense into one capable of competing with the best teams in the SEC. In college football, you cannot win consistently with a one-dimensional team, and unless Tennessee’s defense makes significant strides, it’s unlikely that Heupel will be able to elevate the program to the level of a true SEC contender.
Finally, recruiting has been solid but not enough. While Tennessee is recruiting better than it has in recent years, they are still not on the same level as the top programs in the SEC. The Vols’ recruiting efforts have improved under Heupel, but not at a pace that will allow them to compete with the likes of Georgia and Alabama, who continue to stockpile top-tier talent year after year.
What Can Heupel Do?
Unfortunately, there’s no easy answer for Josh Heupel. Heupel has shown flashes of brilliance, but flashes are not enough to win championships in the SEC. He needs to make substantial changes on both sides of the ball, and quickly, to keep Tennessee relevant in the ultra-competitive SEC.
The most immediate challenge is fixing the offense. Joe Milton needs to find consistency, and Heupel will need to adjust his scheme to accommodate the strengths and weaknesses of his quarterback. The offensive line also needs to be more physical and protect the quarterback better against SEC defenses.
On the defensive side, Tennessee must find a way to stop high-powered offenses. Heupel may need to make changes to the defensive coaching staff or pursue more elite defensive recruits to address this issue. Until the Vols can consistently stop opponents, it will be difficult for Heupel to lead Tennessee to a championship.
Finally, Heupel needs to keep the faith of the fanbase. Tennessee’s patience is wearing thin, and while the program has made progress, it’s clear that Heupel needs to show tangible results soon. The pressure is mounting, and time is running out for him to turn things around.
Conclusion
Josh Heupel is in an impossible situation with the Tennessee Volunteers. The expectations are high, the competition is fierce, and the problems on both sides of the ball are significant. There is no obvious solution to the challenges facing Heupel, and time is not on his side. The coming years will determine whether Heupel can solve these issues and return Tennessee to glory—or if he will be the latest in a long line of coaches to fall short at one of college football’s most demanding programs.
Leave a Reply